The Lake

Original post from my Mom blog here – https://mamaonthemove1.wordpress.com/2026/02/25/book-review-the-lake/

Title: The Lake

Author: Natasha Preston

Genre: Fiction, Thriller, Mystery, Young Adult

Number of Pages: 378

My Rating: 💋💋💋

Book Summary:

Esme and Kayla once were campers at Camp Pine Lake. Now they’re back as counselors-in-training. Esme loves the little girls in her cabin and thinks it’s funny how scared they are of everything—the woods, the bugs, the boys…even swimming in the lake. It reminds her of how she and Kayla used to be. Before…

Because Esme and Kayla did something terrible when they were campers. Something they’ve kept a secret all these years. They vow that this summer will be awesome. Two months of sun, s’mores, and flirting with the cute boy counselors. But then they get a message:
THE LAKE NEVER FORGETS.

The secret they’ve kept buried for so many years is about to resurface.

My Thoughts:

I knew this one would be a quick read, considering I’ve read a few of Natasha’s books already. I can pretty much fly through a young adult novel pretty quickly.

Unfortunately, I thought this one would be a little more thrilling and suspenseful. Don’t get me wrong, I loved the atmosphere of the novel as a whole, set in the woods at a camp, counselors, etc. Definitely gave me a Jason Voorhees, Crystal Lake vibe (which I adore and one of my favourite slasher flicks!) However, this obviously wasn’t that.

The novel surrounds two best friends who are holding a deep dark secret from childhood, but the novel is based in the perspective of Esme. Ultimately, she was the better choice for the narrative, considering I wanted to slap her friend Kayla so many times. Esme at least had some gumption to her, but the slow paranoia and constant anxiety started to get to me near the end. Although there were some character traits that became less then desirable, I understand why the author wrote it that way. How else would a teenage girl react while she is being stalked at a children’s camp?

Kayla was a bit useless to be frank, she only wanted to forget what had happened, never really wanted to discuss the realities of the situation and I felt like she was very selfish and self-centered. She was more interested in her summer boyfriend then the real threat that was happening to her friend Esme and to herself.

There were a few minor characters within the story as well, but honestly they didn’t bring much other then summer romance and some questioning friendships. I kind of called the assistant to the stalker right off the bat, though I wish I had been wrong. I was really hoping that it would have been one of the love interests or even the supervisor of the camp themselves, alas that wasn’t the case.

In the end, their deep dark secret comes spilling out for all to hear and the stalker reveals themself and their heinous plans, a little revenge murder. Why? Because who doesn’t love a psychotic killer/stalker who wants revenge for something that happened to them the night they came in contact with Esme and Kayla. Lillian, the killer/stalker, is cold-hearted, wrathful and will stop at nothing for her revenge.

SPOILER ALERT:

When Esme and Kayla were campers at this exact camp as children, they snuck out one night and started a fire in the woods. They camp across Lillian who was strange, creepy and wanting to show them a dead animal she had killed. There was an altercation between Kayla and Lillian, Kayla pushed her and she feel to the ground unconscious. Unfortunately, at the same time their fire got out of hand and the girls ran back to the cabin, leaving Lillian laying there. The fire starters were never caught and it had always been a mystery as to who had done it. But for the girls, they always kept it quiet and wondered if the girl (Lillian) had made it out safely.

They got their answer in the end.

And Lillian got her revenge, along with a healthy body count of deceased, only to land the blame on someone else and get away.

So did I like this book? It was okay, I wouldn’t re-read it and it’s definitely not in my favourites category, however I just wish their were a few more twists and turns, a bit more escalation on some of the events that occurred and the ending was a bit predictable. All in all, for a young adult thriller I give it three Baci. A good, quick, one time read.

Hope you enjoyed and keep an eye out for the next review which will be the novel Graveyard Shift by M.L. Rio.

Ciao!