Original post from my Mom blog here – https://mamaonthemove1.wordpress.com/2025/09/09/book-review-the-haunting/
Title: The Haunting
Author: Natasha Preston
Genre: Horror, Thriller, Mystery, Young Adult
Number of Pages: 354
My Rating: 💋💋💋💋💋
Book Summary:
Haunted by the past . . .
Penny’s trying to forget about her ex, Nash. His father was arrested for the brutal murder of four teenagers on Devil’s Night last year. Penny’s parents have forbidden her to have anything to do with Nash or his family. It’s hard not to think of what happened as spooky season gets underway–but she’s trying.
That stops when she goes to the Halloween store with her friends to find a costume. What she finds instead is ripped from a horror movie: a girl from school bleeding out on the floor of a dressing room. Stabbed.
Is a copycat killer on the loose? The adults are saying no. But Penny knows better.
My Thoughts:
I’m not going to lie, I really enjoyed this one and it was a quick read for me. I truly didn’t want to put it down. The twists and turns, not to mention I absolutely loved the quick pace of the story. It didn’t give you much downtime, which I personally love in a novel.
I am well aware of the mixed reviews that the author, Natasha Preston, receives for her novels, but come on! Her stories are fast-paced, dark psychological thrillers, the settings are always vivid as if you are there with the characters and definitely emotionally charged. Her endings are definitely something to be desired, but I really don’t mind. I just wish she would maybe include an epilogue, but I digress.
Let me get back to my review here before I completely derail. The characters were emotional, intriguing and traumatized in their own ways.
Penny is our protagonist in this story and immediately you are drawn to her. She is determined, curious, emotional and definitely traumatized. She is still emotionally entangled with her ex, Nash and despite parental restrictions and a whole town ostracizing Nash and his sister, she eventually teams up with him to uncover who is behind the copycat killings. But events start to escalate and it seems she is the main target. She often acts on teenage impulse and emotions, which was written pretty well. Her tenacity drives the plot, though I had to admit it was sometimes frustrating.
Nash, the “troubled” ex-boyfriend is ostracized due to the sins of his father, but he tries to find normalcy and peace among the chaos. Nash becomes Penny’s investigative ally and despite his hesitation to get involved. The town throws him on the suspect list almost instantly, but could he do this? Penny doesn’t believe so and you can tell that he too is still emotionally entangled with Penny, but really doesn’t know how to go back to the way it was. In the end, it does cost him.
Nash’s sister Grace is also a “main” character, but she is more in the background for most of the story. I’d consider her part of the narrative, but less prominent. She is also shunned by the town and you can clearly sense hurt when she is first introduced. However, she definitely lands on the suspect list for the town very early….Like father, like daughter?
Penny’s rag-tag group of friends are also minor characters in their story line, but great additions. Adi is Penny’s best friend, her ride or die if you will. She is there with her fun attitude and supportive nature. Zayn is caring and often checks in – helping Penny throughout the novel. Omar is the goofball, horror aficionado and brings more of a light vibe throughout the novel.
The Haunting delivers a fast-paced, 90’s teen slasher vibe. While the character development wasn’t intricate in any way, the main focus seemed to be on Penny and Nash. Everyone else was more face value….for the most part. No spoilers of course! I felt like this moved the story along, solidifying the teen slasher atmosphere and mystery that comes along with it; ‘Who is behind all of it and Why?‘ I was okay with not having this as a in-depth and emotionally engaging read.
I wanted something more “light” and a bit, in my opinion, campy. I enjoyed it, I must have if I finished it so quickly! I personally like Natasha Preston as an author and I’m sure I’ll be reading more of her in the future. But please, can we maybe get an Epilogue in the next novel?!
Currently reading The Midnight Feast by Lucy Foley and to be honest, I’m almost finished.
Hope you enjoyed and keep an eye out for the next review!
Ciao!
Beneath the Book Light 